Help STOP Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH)

Unabashed Truth about AFFH, Protecting Property Rights and Local Government Authority

Home » Youth Influx Revives Cities

Youth Influx Revives Cities

Introduction by Smith Young “:)” If you are not a subscriber to the WSJ, the article below is provided below, photo’s deleted.


The free market gentrification of cities described by Laura Kusisto for the WSJ, if it continues, is going to create a big problem for the federal Dept. of Housing and Urban Development, HUD, and the new (insultingly named) Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing, AFFH, rule that requires about 1,200 communities accepting grants to effectively give up their local government authority based on using HUD’s data and mapping tool loaded with census data on race, education, employment, poverty index, and English speaking households.  First and foremost AFFH is all about race, not affordable housing, and the reason this gentrification causes a problem is that HUD leverages what it calls Racially/Ethnically-Concentrated Areas of Poverty, R/ECAPs, against the suburbs to insert itself into local planning, that is as long as the community continues to take HUD grants.  HUD needs racial disparities between the cities and suburbs to continue its AFFH program.

So how can HUD fight the free market?  Deceitfully is the answer and here’s how.  Interestingly enough, HUD posed questions and requested comments due May 23, 2016.  One of the questions was:

  1. Should R/ECAPs (Racially or Ethnically Concentrated Areas of Poverty) be amended to exclude college students from the calculation of poverty rate?

On behalf of yours truly submitted the following comment to HUD:

“Current and future college students in R/ECAPs will offset and reduce disparities due to the higher achievement and average household income levels; especially for part time students who work full time.  Including students also has a direct effect on the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Tool (AFFHT) with regard to measuring education levels (school proficiency data map), employment (Labor Engagement Index), poverty (Poverty Index with race/ethnicity, national origin),  and English speaking (Limited English Proficiency, LEP) households.  In summary college students raise the goodness of the R/ECAP statistics closing the gap with more affluent entitlement jurisdictions.  Higher achieving Black and Hispanic families in R/ECAPs with college students similarly lower the R/ECAP statistical poverty rate.

Excluding college students in R/ECAPs allows HUD to effectively pick winners and losers by increasing R/ECAP poverty rates thus further empowering HUD’s ability to enforce AFFH.

Lastly, the number of millennials is now equal to the number of baby boomers and part of what is driving suburban redevelopment now is the migration by young Americans, particularly the college-educated, out of the suburbs to city centers. From 2000 to 2010, for instance, the population of college-educated 25- to 34-year-old residents in down towns grew 44%, three times as fast as the rest of the metro areas for the 50 largest cities, according to a pair of researchers from University of California, Berkeley, and the University of Pennsylvania.”

The Wall Street Journal
Influx of Younger, Wealthier Residents Transforms U.S. Cities

By Laura Kusisto, June 10, 2016

Educated, relatively high-earning workers are flocking to urban neighborhoods at a rate not seen since at least the 1970s

CLEVELAND—Joe Baur grew up in a leafy suburb a half-hour outside central Cleveland. But when it came time to settle down with his wife, the couple chose Ohio City, a neighborhood here that until recently was pockmarked by abandoned businesses and decaying homes.

Mr. Baur, a 29-year-old travel writer, and Melanie, a 28-year-old international-relations worker, love that their neighborhood is brimming with new restaurants and bars. The couple pays just over $1,000 a month for a one-bedroom loft—an amount that easily could cover monthly mortgage payments for a three-bedroom house in the suburbs. But both say they have no interest.

The Baurs are part of a wave of young, educated, relatively high-earning workers flocking to many American cities at a rate not seen since the U.S. Census Bureau began tracking such data in the 1970s. The shift began last decade and accelerated during the housing bust.

The movement is injecting new life into tired urban cores, prompting renovation of older residential and commercial buildings while spurring new real estate developments as well as upgrades to transit systems, parks and cultural institutions.

A wave of young, educated, high-earning workers are flooding city neighborhoods like Ohio City, in Cleveland, creating challenges and opportunities for urban development. Photo: Rich-Joseph Facun for The Wall Street Journal

A range of factors is driving the urban influx, economists say, from job growth and declining crime in cities to young professionals waiting longer to have children—or deciding not to have them at all. Tighter mortgage lending and concern about homeownership risks also weigh on young people, turning many into long-term renters.

The trend is boosting urban housing values. City rents nationwide are now nearly $1,730 a month on average, compared with just under $1,250 for their suburban counterparts, according to CoStar Group Inc. The average urban home is worth 2% more than the average suburban home, according to real-estate information company Zillow. In 2010, suburban homes were worth 4% more.

For landlords and developers, rising rents and home values are a boon. But the costs can push out lower-wage employees as well as teachers, police and other middle-income public servants, making it harder for employers to attract such labor.

[photo deleted]

[photo deleted]

West 25th Street, top, a main thoroughfare in Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood, is filled with restaurants, craft breweries and shops. Above, the neighborhood’s West Side Market, in business since 1912, remains a community magnet.PHOTOS: RICH-JOSEPH FACUN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

As many of the displaced move to suburbs, new strains are emerging there, on schools, transportation and services for the needy.

“The housing affordability issues are no longer limited to the high-cost coastal cities” such as New York and San Francisco, said Stockton Williams, executive director of the Urban Land Institute’s Terwilliger Center for Housing.

In fact, the growth in urban wealth was apparent in all 26 cities included in a recent study of U.S. Census data by Jed Kolko, a senior fellow at the Terner Center for Housing Innovation at the University of California, Berkeley. Mr. Kolko’s analysis begins in 2000, a period that includes the entire housing boom, bust and recovery.

The study found that among the top 30% of all U.S. households by income—those earning about $85,000 a year and up—400,000 more lived in urban neighborhoods in 2014 than did at the peak of the housing boom in 2006.

Even in Cleveland, which has been hit by the foreclosure crisis and a shrinking population, the share of young, educated residents in downtown neighborhoods rose by half, to 12% in 2014 from 8% in 2000, according to Mr. Kolko’s research. This group includes residents 25 to 44 years old who have a college degree.

In the Ohio City neighborhood, the median income skyrocketed to $93,000 from $23,000 since 2006, according to Ohio City Inc., a local nonprofit development group. Median home values shot up 800% since 2000 to $270,000, according to Ohio City Inc. Median rental prices in downtown Cleveland as a whole jumped 47% from late 2010 to late 2015, according to the Center for Population Dynamics at Cleveland State University.

[photo deleted]

[photo deleted]

In Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood, apartments and retail spaces are under construction, top. Above, an empty lot near these houses in the revived neighborhood recently sold for $90,000.PHOTOS: RICH-JOSEPH FACUN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Tom McNair, executive director of Ohio City Inc., said that five years ago his group was focused on tackling a 40% vacancy rate for office and retail space on the main commercial strip. Today, with a vacancy rate below 2% those spaces are teeming with bars, restaurants and craft breweries. An ice cream factory occupies a former nightclub space where gun shots once rang out.

“Everybody wants to open a business, buy a property, build housing,” said Sam McNulty, a local entrepreneur.

Anne Hartnett started a successful spin studio in the neighborhood. But she was priced out of buying a larger home for her family and had to move to a nearby suburb to get more space.

“It was kind of an ironic situation that a neighborhood we had really put a lot of energy into revitalizing we ended up not being able to afford,” she said.

[photo deleted]

Sam McNulty, co-founder of the Ohio City Restaurant Group, with his dog, Bo, at his brewery in Cleveland’s Ohio City neighborhood, which has seen a surge in stores and restaurants. PHOTO: RICH-JOSEPH FACUN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

Now Mr. McNair is trying to figure out how to hold onto middle-class families. His group is working with Cleveland on rezoning to encourage the creation of 500 new units of housing, with a goal of having 10% of that be affordable. Already, 800 units are under development—among the biggest bursts of activity the neighborhood has seen since the 1920s, local officials say.

Those who have moved to revived city neighborhoods say they love the new amenities. And for some there is another plus: no need for a car.

Joe and Melanie Baur, in Ohio City, say they bike, take public transit and walk, including jaunts with their dog, Moses Cleaveland, named after the city’s founder, who spelled his surname with an extra “a.”

The car “was such an albatross,” Mr. Baur said. “I hated it.”

Write to Laura Kusisto at

Please follow and like us:

Name of author

Name: Smith Young

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *